Are We Making Parenting Too Tough?

The Instapundit has a pretty thought-provoking article on parenting. Considering my stage of life and that of most of friends (married for a few years in most cases, with some in the group starting to have children), it's definitely worth reading. The idea that the social costs on parenting that are now imposed by government are making people less likely to conceive is definitely worth thinking about...

Parenting was always hard work, of course. But aside from the economic payoffs, parents used to get a lot of social benefits, too. But in recent decades, a collection of parenting "experts" and safety-fascist types have extinguished some of the benefits while raising the costs, to the point where what's amazing isn't that people are having fewer kids, but that people are having kids at all.

...Today's middle-class kids are always under the adult eye. It's not clear that the kids are better off for all this supervision -- and they're certainly fatter, perhaps because they get around less outside -- but the burden on parents is much, much higher. And it's exacted in a million tiny yet irritating other ways. Some are worthwhile -- car seats, for example, are probably a net gain in safety -- but even there the cost is high: I heard a radio host in Knoxville making fun of SUVs and minivans: When he was a kid, he boasted, his parents took their five children cross-country in an Impala sedan. Nowadays, you'd never make it without being cited for neglect. And you can't get five kids in a sedan if they all have to have car seats, which these days they seem to require until they're 18.

...You're responsible for your kids in ways previous generations weren't, but your ability to discipline them is much reduced, and as my wife (a forensic psychologist) notes, the bad kids know that they can cow most adults by threatening to call 911 and make a bogus abuse charge. And forget disciplining your child, even with a harsh word, in a public place: At the very least, if you do you'll be looked on not as a virtuous parent helping to preserve the social fabric, but as that worst of all sinners in contemporary American culture: a meanie. And schools, anxious for parental "involvement," place far more demands on parents than they did when I was a kid.

There's also the decline in parental prestige over generations. My mother reports that when she was a newlywed (she was married in 1959) you weren't seen as fully a member of the adult world until you had kids. Nowadays to have kids means something closer to an expulsion from the adult world. People in the suburbs buy SUVs instead of minivans not because they need the four-wheel-drive capabilities, but because the SUVs lack the minivan's close association with low-prestige activities like parenting, and instead provide the aura of high-prestige activities like whitewater kayaking. Why should kayaking be more prestigious than parenting? Because parenting isn't prestigious in our society. If it were, childless people would drive minivans just to partake of the aura.

That last point seems to be overly broad, but I think Reynolds is correct that we don't attach a lot of glamour in our popular culture to having kids and raising them in a tight-knit family. Reynolds is also right that we can't just give people economic benefits for having children through subsidies. We can't just make it easier for people to become parents by asking the government to help; we need to make it easier for people to be good parents by taking steps to make our culture more friendly to parenting.

And We Return... and Tony Snow Scores a TKO

I'm back. Thanks for the cards and letters.

Seriously, the absence pained me more than any one of my nine readers. But let's re-open for business by posting this link to Tony Snow taking Helen Thomas apart this morning in the White House press room. I've been waiting years to see someone basically shred up one of her stupid questions, and he did it perfectly. Not only that, but the end of the clip, where he briefly discusses his battle with cancer last year... let's just say this may be the best job decision the President made since he appointed John Roberts (Alito doesn't count because it was originally Harriet Myers). The President has a long way to go to win back conservative support, particularly on immigration. But Tony Snow's a great spokesman.