Monday, August 29, 2011

ManBearPig Strikes Again

In Al Gore's telling, the advocates who are fighting global warming are the equivalent of the civil rights activists on the 1950's and 1960's.  Remember, when you want to convince people on the other side of a scientific battle that they're wrong, it's a good idea to equate them with racists, while at the same time demeaning the actual accomplishment of the civil rights movement.  That's a winning argument.

Labels: ,

Thursday, October 28, 2010

I'm Not An Elitist, Although I Play One On TV

The blogosphere is having a big debate about elites and their role in society.  It started with Ron Brownsetin at National Journal and Jon Chait at The New Republic lamenting what the left sees as improper climate change skepticism by conservatives here in the U.S., whereas conservatives in other Western nations, particularly in Europe, are far more willing to accept the case for climate change.  Ross Douthat demolishes Chait's belief that the predominance of libertarian economic dogma in U.S. politics is the driving force.  As Douthat accurately notes, the real reason for more skepticism among American politicians is because American democracy is far more responsive to the people -- and in both Europe and the United States, the populace at large are equally skeptical about the case for climate change.

This led to a bit of honesty from Ezra Klein, followed by the usual tripe...
This isn't a very popular statement, but there is a role for elites in public life. Just like I want knowledgeable CEOs running companies and knowledgeable doctors performing surgeries, I want knowledgeable legislators crafting public policy. That's why we have a representative democracy, rather than some form of government-by-referendum. But of late, the elites in the Republican Party are abdicating their roles, preferring to pander to the desire for free tax cuts and the hostility to Al Gore than make tough and potentially unpopular decisions to safeguard our future.
Forget the last sentence, which is the usual hyperbole of liberal certainty that they're right and conservatives are just denying reality by refusing to agree.  The first three sentences are a fascinating way of summarizing modern-day liberal governance.  Jim Manzi's response is fantastic and worth reading in full, but here's a great excerpt...
Bill Buckley famously said that he “would rather by governed by the first 2,000 names in the Boston telephone directory than by the Harvard faculty.” So would I. But I would rather fly in an airplane with wings designed by one competent aeronautical engineer than one with wings designed by a committee of the first 20,000 names of non-engineers in the Boston phonebook. The value of actual expertise in a technical field like wing design outweighs the advantages offered by incorporating multiple points of view.


The essential Progressive belief that Klein expresses in undiluted form is that crafting public policy through legislation is a topic for which, in simplified terms, the benefits of expertise outweigh the benefits of popular contention. Stated more cautiously, this would be the belief that the institutional rules of the game should be more heavily tilted toward expert opinion on many important topics than they are in the U.S. today.


This would be a lot more compelling if the elites didn’t have such a terrible track record of producing social interventions that work.
Bingo.

Let's start with an admission.  Look, I love the Tea Party's energy, I love its ideas, I love its objectives, I love its candidates (by and large), and I love the fact Tea Party adherents are by and large bracingly honest.  This is a citizen movement where citizens are actually demanding better, and participating more.  That's a good thing in just about every way.  At the same time, I'm someone who is wary of populism, and the Tea Party is a populist movement, even if it's the rare movement that is both populist and largely libertarian.

But I'd rather live in a country governed by Tea Party populists than Ivy League elitists.

This is not a rebellion against expert opinion so much as a belief that experts are far more likely to be inflexible and more convinced of their own brilliance, without a real world appreciation of why their approach may create more problems.  In addition, since the experts are so brilliant, I'd rather have them convincing the non-expert leaders than the non-experts trying to convince the experts why they are wrong.   Megan McArdle says this to some degree as well, but I think it really is the key for my own preference.

As for the public's preference... look, democracy can be a bitch, because you're stuck with the decisions of an electorate that by and large may not pay attention to what's going on enough to be able to agree with your brilliant idea.  But if you're so smart that you can solve all of the problems, you should be smart enough to convince your fellow citizens of your brilliance. 

Labels: ,

Wednesday, March 03, 2010

Giving Us The Gas

Oh, yes, this will be popular...
To meet the Obama administration’s targets for cutting greenhouse gas emissions, some researchers say, Americans may have to experience a sobering reality: gas at $7 a gallon.


To reduce carbon dioxide emissions in the transportation sector 14 percent from 2005 levels by 2020, the cost of driving must simply increase, according to a forthcoming report by researchers at Harvard’s Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs.


The 14 percent target was set in the Environmental Protection Agency’s budget for fiscal 2010.
I'm going to go out on a limb and say that if gas prices hit $7 a gallon, the administration won't need to worry about the populace being irate over healthcare. They'll be trying to avoid people with pitchforks instead.

Labels: ,

Monday, February 22, 2010

But I'm Sure They're Buying Carbon Offsets

Remember, global warming is a crucial issue -- it's so crucial that U.N. environmental conferences need to take place in Bali, and fly in 1,500 people to do so.

Labels:

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Prove To Me That The Sky Isn't Falling, Then

Docto Zero over at Hot Air names the biggest killer of all-time...

Hitler? Stalin? Pol Pot? Not even close. A single book called Silent Spring killed far more people than all those fiends put together.

Published in 1962, Silent Spring used manipulated data and wildly exaggerated claims (sound familiar?) to push for a worldwide ban on the pesticide known as DDT – which is, to this day, the most effective weapon against malarial mosquitoes. The Environmental Protection Agency held extensive hearings after the uproar produced by this book… and these hearings concluded that DDT should not be banned. A few months after the hearings ended, EPA administrator William Ruckleshaus over-ruled his own agency and banned DDT anyway, in what he later admitted was a “political” decision. Threats to withhold American foreign aid swiftly spread the ban across the world.

The resulting explosion of mosquito-borne malaria in Africa has claimed over sixty million lives. This was not a gradual process – a surge of infection and death happened almost immediately. The use of DDT reduces the spread of mosquito-borne malaria by fifty to eighty percent, so its discontinuation quickly produced an explosion of crippling and fatal illness. The same environmental movement which has been falsifying data, suppressing dissent, and reading tea leaves to support the global-warming fraud has studiously ignored this blood-drenched “hockey stick” for decades.

I couldn't pretend to be an expert on climate science or on DDT (okay, I could pretend -- but it would probably be as bad as a Jimmy Fallon comedy routine). But the folks who believe in manmade global warming have a problem right now -- they've based their argument largely on the idea that manmade global warming is settled science, and that the folks who disagree are either complete idiots or are acting out of monetary self-interest. Unfortunately, the data to support the claims for man-made global warming has come into question. This doesn't disprove the theory, but it should mean that the people supporting it need to provide more evidence. Unfortunately, they seem to have the idea of proof backwards, as the former head of the East Anglia Cimate Research Unit seeks to shift the burden of proof to skeptics...
Jones said he might submit a correction to Nature. But he nonetheless attacked bloggers and other critics for "hijacking the peer-review process... Why don't they do their own [temperature] reconstructions? If they want to criticise, they should write their own papers," he said.
Ed Morrissey gets the response to this idiotic question right...
Well, let’s see — could it be because we’re not the people advancing extraordinary claims about man-made influence on global weather patterns? This must be some new, previously unknown tenet of the Scientific Method, wherein people who point out errors, bias, bad process, and unsubstantiated claims from scientists are somehow required to disprove their unsupported hypotheses. It’s apparently no longer incumbent on Jones and his colleagues to substantiate their own conjectures with actual science, rather than use badly-lifted speculation from media interviews and unsupported propaganda from advocacy groups.
Maybe Doctor Zero is on to something. I'm also guessing that this makes a cap and trade bill this year as likely as the Sixers winning the NBA Title.

Labels: , , ,

Saturday, February 13, 2010

Weird Science

Here's Dr. Demento, a.k.a. Howard Dean, explaining how Republicans don't believe in science...
“One of the most disturbing things about the Republican Party over the last couple of decades is that they just don’t believe in science any more. And that is not an approach that is likely to generate any kind of creative thinking…People who use snowstorms as an example of why global warming doesn’t exist don’t understand the science and they don’t care.”
You know, one of the most disturbing things about the Democratic Party over the last decade or so is that they consider men like Howard Dean to be leaders. Ed Morrissey does a nice job taking Dean apart...
Actually, we do respect science. What we don’t do is adopt belief systems based on hypotheses from so-called scientists that use incomplete and unreliable predictive modeling, include wild conjectures as fact, pass off student dissertations as reliable research, and accept advocacy claims without testing, all while conspiring to hide contradictory evidence and scheme to ruin the careers of those who question them. Science requires that claims get tested, that predictive models that fail get discarded, that data and process remain open for review, and that critical thinking get welcomed instead of demonized.

Now, when Howard Dean wants to discuss scientifically how anyone can represent what the IPCC did as rigorous and reliable science, and how the “science” that predicted unstoppable increases in global temperatures for the last 12 years got it wrong but still remains reliable as a basis on which to enact public policy that massively intrudes on private enterprise, property rights, and energy production, well, I’d bet the GOP would welcome such a forum. But while we’re there, perhaps Dean and the scientific acolytes in the Democratic Party can scientifically explain how a group of cells with a unique, human DNA that divide and multiply within a uterus is somehow
not human life.
I'm not holding my breath on a response from Vermont's former Governor. The problem with Dean's formulation of climate science is that it accepts conclusions without a critical examination of the data and underlying assumptions. Most of the people mocking global warming by pointing to recent weather patterns do so as a joke. It's far more disingenuous to rely on false data to conclude that manmade global warming exists. And that's what the folks at the IPCC appear to have been doing. And the fact that dean may still believe in it would be pretty disturbing, if anyone actually listened to him.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, December 16, 2009

Copenhagen Not Coping So Well

Oh, goody. Things at the climate change conference are getting a little, um, hot...
The Copenhagen climate change conference appeared to be imploding from within and exploding from without on Wednesday.

Police fired tear gas, brandished batons and detained more than 200 protesters who tried to push through the security cordon around the Bella Center, as negotiations inside bogged down, for the second time this week, over differences between China and the West over emissions, funding issues and transparency.

"People around the world [are] actually expecting something to be done from us,” red-faced Danish Prime Minister Lars Rasmussen lectured delegates from nearly 200 nations.

Sen. John Kerry (D-Mass.), the highest-ranking American yet to appear at the talks, urged attendees to put aside their differences and “make Friday our day of success.”

Minutes earlier — in a surprise move that captured growing uncertainty over conference — Denmark’s climate minister, Connie Hedegaard, stepped aside as president of the conference, handing the gavel to Rasmussen, as head of the host country.

Outside, Danish police — who have been accused of heavy-handedness by human rights groups — clashed with thousands of environmental activists who descended on the complex from a nearby train station and demanded entry to the Bella Center.

...On Tuesday, Hedegaard made an emotional appeal for countries to put aside their differences to finalize a deal — after the G-77 bloc of developing nations accused her of trying to ram through an agreement amenable to the U.S. and other big industrialized nations.

But no sooner had Rasmussen assumed the presidency than those tensions burst out in the open again, with China, India, Bolivia, South Africa and Sudan saying they would block attempts by the Danish delegation to produce a draft text favored by most Western countries.

Minutes after taking the gavel, Rasmussen angrily denounced developing countries for seeking to delay consideration of the text, accusing them of focusing on "procedure, procedure, procedure."

He was immediately rebuked by a representative of China, a member of the G-77 bloc, who said moving forward too quickly was tantamount to "obstructionism" and a bullying attempt by the West.
This thing was bound to have problems, if John Kerry was involved. And that's before we consider the implications of Climategate, where the evidence keeps piling up that data was being manipulated, and the integrity of the data sets worldwide is now open to serious question. Indeed, Charlie Martin does a pretty good job explaining how access to the full set of data has already cast doubt on the controversial "hockey stick" graph. As he notes, the trick that was used to "hide the decline" actually looks much worse when we have all the data placed into the graph.

Brian Micklethwaite sums up the situation...
I've just been watching this video, of Lord Monkton laying into the Climategate gang. What makes it so potent is that he is quite bluntly calling them crooks, and calling anyone who still follows their fraudulent prophecies dupes and fools. He names names, and crimes. Yes, crimes. And yes, criminals. Criminals with names. Monkton does all this in his posh British public school voice. Nevertheless, you can almost see him doing that thing that fist fighters do, but with their beckoning hands rather than with their mouths, and pointing at their own chins. Come and get me! Give me your best shot! I say you are a pack of scoundrels. Prove me wrong! I say that the logical thing to do about "climate change" is: nothing. Nothing. Why on earth do you still have the damned nerve to think anything else? Such pugilistic vulgarities are not to be found in the text of the talk. Monkton is too canny, too cool, to get that excited. But that is the subtext.
...You can feel that most crucial of propaganda processes happening with Climategate: the reversing of the burden of proof. Unfair to all the fraud detectives (Watts, McIntyre, and the rest of them, including Monkton himself) though it undoubtedly was, those noble toilers, until the Climategate revelations erupted, had to prove everything, in defiance of the default position. Their every tiny blemish was jumped upon. Their major claims were ignored. Now the default position is slowly mutating into: It's all made-up nonsense. And the burden of proof is shifting onto the shoulders of all those who want to go on believing in such ever more discredited alarmism. In short, our side is winning this argument, big time.

And it turns out that the rich countries do indeed wish to remain rich, as I merely hoped was the case a week ago. The underlying point being: nobody is actually as scared about climate change as they were a few months back. Doubters who feared that there might have been "something in it", "no smoke without fire", etc., now doubt far more completely. All but the craziest warmists are now going rather quieter. The people who matter no longer feel deep in their guts, those of them who ever did, that there has to be a deal, or the earth will fry. All potential parties to it are now more willing than they were to walk away from Copenhagen with no deal, because the fear of being blamed for not reaching a deal is now (in the nick of time) being replaced by the fear of being accused of having reached a bad deal.
(hat tip: Instapundit) Sounds a bit like (a) the health care debate, and (b) a tipping point on climate change debate. The real problem for folks who believe that global warming is a real problem is that their credibility is in doubt, and that's going to be difficult to re-establish now.

Labels: ,