Friday, October 15, 2010

We're Not So Wild About Harry

Cool.  Harry Reid now thinks the surge worked. 

After we repeal healthcare, he'll probably tell us he pushed healthcare reform so we could repeal it and improve healthcare.

Let me be honest about this -- election night will not feel very good if we don't remove this weenie from office.  Even Democrats need to be embarrassed that this is the toxic idiot their party promotes as its Majority Leader in the Senate.  Put it another way: I may not like or agree with Mitch McConnell, but I don't actively cringe every time he opens his mouth.  If Democrats don't do that when Harry speaks, they probably stopped listening a long time ago. 

Labels: ,

Thursday, March 11, 2010

The Health Care Follies Continue

Interesting nugget from a Time article that talks about Chuckles Schumer and Dick Durbin fighting over Harry Reid's position as Senate Majority Leader, even before Reid possibly loses his election this fall...
The first time leadership aides noticed something was amiss was during the health care debate last November, when Schumer made some notable overtures to the progressive wing of the party. He'd previously taken flack from progressives for his championing of Kirsten Gillibrand, a moderate Dem from upstate New York who was appointed to Hillary Clinton's seat. Just after Senate Finance Committee chairman Max Baucus passed a bipartisan health reform bill out of his committee, Schumer demanded that the public option — a liberal provision that provided government competition to private insurers — be put back in. Reid initially bowed to Schumer's pressure but weeks later had to drop the provision in order to secure all 60 Democratic votes to overcome a Republican filibuster threat. That delay would come back to haunt the Democrats after the New Year, when Scott Brown's surprise victory in the Massachusetts Senate race cost them their critical 60th vote.
I'm thinking that if health care reform fails, the Tea Party movement should send thank you notes to Schumer for being an ambitious jerk. On more substantive matters, The Hill has another Whip count, with the expected number of no votes on health care from Dems to be 25 as of now; if my math is correct, Pelosi can't afford to lose more than 12-15 more Dems or the game is over. In other words, Bart Stupak's coalition will probably decide it. Unless, of course, more Democrats follow the lead of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus, which is now threatening to torpedo the bill unless their concerns over illegal immigrants get addressed as part of the package...
Since last fall, Congressional Hispanic Caucus (CHC) members have kept quiet, at least publicly, about their objections to the immigration provisions in the Senate bill.


The Senate language would prohibit illegal immigrants’ buying healthcare coverage from the proposed health exchanges. The House-passed bill isn’t as restrictive, but it does — like the Senate bill — bar illegal immigrants from receiving federal subsidies to buy health insurance.


Hispanic Democrats say they haven’t moved from their stance that they will not vote for a healthcare bill containing the Senate’s prohibitions.


...On Wednesday, members of the CHC privately acknowledged they’ve told their leaders that anyone who is assuming they’ve backed away from their position is in for a rude awakening.


“The [Hispanic] Caucus didn’t want to raise it as an issue too early,” one Hispanic Democrat said Wednesday. “But it’s real. It’s a problem.”


Those alarm bells have apparently been heard. CHC Chairwoman Nydia Velázquez (D-N.Y.) said she and others have, on behalf of two dozen Hispanic Democrats, been in discussions with Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) and other leaders about how to resolve the matter.


“And we will continue having discussions,” Velazquez said.


However, it is unlikely that the Senate will be able to change the immigration provisions under reconciliation rules. And even if it is deemed possible, there may not be enough support in either chamber of Congress to do it.


Not every member of the CHC would stand in the way of healthcare over the immigration issue. As a House leader, it would be unlikely for Becerra to vote against the president’s signature domestic policy priority. And centrist Rep. Henry Cuellar (D-Texas) said the Senate language is “not a deal-killer” for him.
Somewhere, Congressman Joe Wilson is laughing.  That last statement by Cuellar probably gives away the game -- as noted by Ed Morrissey, the Caucus members probably just want an assurance from President Obama that he will indeed take up immigration reform this year, as he promised last year. But if the bill starts to look unlikely to pass, the votes against it could snowball based on people suddenly discovering "principled" reasons for opposition.

Meanwhile, perhaps we're getting closer to the final bill, or to a real end to it, as Speaker Pelosi and House Majority Leader Hoyer have now canceled all Committee hearings and gone behind closed doors with the party leadership, providing us with more of the transparent, open government promised by the President. Jake Tapper says a compromise bill is close to being complete.

Maybe they have the votes and are doing a little champagne toast in Ted Kennedy's honor or something, but I tend to think that if they had the votes, a vote would be scheduled before another Democratic congressman melts down in an ethics scandal (or worse, disclosed more details about what goes on in the House gym showers).

So do they have the votes?  My thought is that if they did, we wouldn't see ideas like this get floated...
House Rules Chairwoman Louise Slaughter is prepping to help usher the healthcare overhaul through the House and potentially avoid a direct vote on the Senate overhaul bill, the chairwoman said Tuesday. Slaughter is weighing preparing a rule that would consider the Senate bill passed once the House approves a corrections bill that would make changes to the Senate version.


Slaughter has not taken the plan to Speaker Pelosi as Democrats await CBO scores on the corrections bill. "Once the CBO gives us the score we'll spring right on it, " she said.
And I thought reconciliation was a bad idea politically. By contrast, this is toxic. The Heritage Foundation refers to this nicely as "procedural fraud." Forget the optics of the issue -- this is one sure way to guarantee that we'll be debating the legitimacy of the bill as law forever. In their fervor to pass the bill, Democrats are undermining Congress and the legitimacy of the legislative process. What's really bad is that I don't think I'm exaggerating, if they pursue this latest procedural flimflam. Deeming the bill passed -- I'm sure the Democrats will be chagrined when this gets used against them some day in the future.

As to whether they have the votes, Pelosi has already indicated the White House's March 18th deadline may not be workable.  Michael Barone says the votes don't look like they are there yet. We'll see if that changes, or if the Dems merely change the rules again -- maybe the Democrats will find a way to claim that a minority is a majority.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Friday, February 26, 2010

The Health Care Follies Continue

Where to start when discussing the health care summit? I'd start with Arnold Kling's pre-game conclusion...
There are two ways to approach reducing the use of high-cost, low-benefit procedures. You can have the government tell people what they can and cannot have. Or you can have individuals pay for a larger fraction of the medical procedures that they consume. It really comes down to those choices.

Advocating either one of those is political suicide, and talking about anything else is a waste of time. The Democrats will not advocate government rationing, and the Republicans will not advocate scrapping most of our current system of third-party payment in medicine. Instead, the summit, like the entire "health reform debate" this year, will be a waste of time.
As to the postgame, Slate has a decent analysis...
If the White House health care summit was political theater, here's a 30-second review: President Obama won. So did congressional Republicans. Democrats in Congress need another act. This is not because Obama is such a better speaker and advocate for the legislation than his allies, though he is. It's because Democrats didn't get much political benefit from the event.

Obama ran for office promising to reach out to the other party. He said he would try to find areas of common agreement, and when his opponents had a legitimate philosophical disagreement, he would not question their motives. He did all of that in the session. Obama was not the crazy liberal caricature of GOP attacks during the seven-hour iron-bottom discussion. (Which may itself have been bad for the health of the people in the room.)

Republicans came out ahead for the same reason: They did not look like hell-bent obstructionists. This isn't to say that they tried to meet the president halfway. They didn't even try to meet him a quarter of the way. Repeatedly they called on him to start over. The president tried to get the room to focus on areas of agreement, and though several Republicans—notably Sen. Tom Coburn and Rep. Dave Camp—worked in that spirit, several others (hello, Reps. John Boehner and Eric Cantor) did not.
If you want a good answer for why the GOP looked better than the Democrats, take a look at the opening speakers for each side. The GOP presented Lamar Alexander -- reasonable, calm, looking like everyone's favorite uncle, and laying out the principles and ideas that GOP backed for reform. The Dems, if you take out Obama since he's the President and moderator in this format, went with Nancy Pelosi. And then followed her with Harry Reid. The only way they could have made it worse was by sending in Joe Biden. Pelosi spent her time talking about the moral case for reform, invoking Ted Kennedy's dream, as if that will sway independant voters. Reid came armed with the first of many sob stories, while making the laughable claim that the Democrats haven't discussed reconciliation. Even liberals think he's full of it on that point. Yuval Levin's halftime analysis contained some important nuggets of truth...
First, the Democrats appear to have no particular purpose in mind for this event. They’re not driving anywhere, or making a clear individual case, while Republicans clearly want to get across the point that we should scrap the current bills and start over in pursuit of a few incremental steps. The Democrats may have thought that simply putting the spotlight on Republicans when the subject is health care would make the GOP look bad. But Republicans so far seem prepared enough and focused enough to avoid that, and to make the Democrats look rather aimless by comparison.

...Third, an important part of the Democrats’ problem is that Obama himself is their only star, and this format is not working for him. He certainly seems engaged and well informed (even given a few misstatements of fact, at least one of which John Kyl made very clear.) But he doesn’t seem like the President of the United States—more like a slightly cranky committee chairman or a patronizing professor who thinks that saying something is “a legitimate argument” is a way to avoid having an argument. He is diminished by the circumstances, he’s cranky and prickly when challenged, and he’s got no one to help him. The other Democrats around the table have been worse than unimpressive.

...It’s easy to dismiss all this by saying no one is watching anyway, but that’s not quite true. The purpose of this spectacle is not so much to move the public as to move Democratic members of Congress—to create some momentum that might last long enough to help wavering Democrats cast a very painful vote. That audience very likely is watching, and they are seeing their leadership fail to make a straightforward case for the Democratic approach to health care, or to respond to the most basic Republican objections about high costs, excessive spending, overregulation, and the effect of this plan on American families. They are managing to lose an argument about health care to Republican members of Congress—no mean feat.
Tunku Varadjian offers similar thoughts...
...The marathon TV teach-in—in which Obama was more schoolmarm than president—should be regarded by Democrats as a great disappointment. They made no clear gain, and won no clear argument. It became apparent from the very beginning—when a testy Obama said “Let me finish, Lamar!” to the courtly Lamar Alexander—that this was not to be an open-minded exploration of the issues in question. It was, instead, a simulacrum of a debate, a pretend-conversation, one in which Obama established, yet again, his command over fact and detail, but in which he also revealed reflexive superciliousness, intolerance of different opinions, and a shortness of patience unbecoming of a president. (He also showed that he’s a tedious clock-Nazi, cutting people off all the time, while showing no inclination to edit himself.)

What was so striking about the summit was the preparedness of the Republicans. All of them had done their homework: Lamar Alexander, Tom Coburn, Jon Kyl, John McCain, Dave Camp, John Barrasso, and Paul Ryan.

The Democrats, by contrast, suffered from an acute case of “anecdotitis” (is it a preexisting condition?): Almost all of them delivered speeches that boasted a story or two meant to tug at the heart. Obama set the tone with his account of Sasha’s asthma, Malia’s meningitis, and his mom’s ovarian cancer. Nancy and Harry—as Obama called them—told us, respectively, of having “seen grown men cry,” and of a “young man called Jesus” who was stiffed by his insurers. Steny Hoyer gave us a sob story, Louise Slaughter told us about a woman who had to wear her dead sister’s teeth, Tom Harkin told us of a letter he got “yesterday, from a farmer in Iowa…” This constant argument-by-anecdote was relentlessly populist; but it was also fatally weak, as it was the infantilizing of a national audience, an invitation to Americans to wince and say, “Gee, things are bad out there. We need this bill!”
On the anecdotes, I keep finding myself thinking of Helen Lovejoy on the Simpsons saying, "Won't somebody please think of the children?!" Or as Robert Stacey McCain noted, the Dems seem to be saying, “A killer whale with a pre-existing condition ate that poor girl’s deductible!”

There's a point here about the Democrats' performance perhaps making Obama look better (or more importantly, making the case for why the mainstream press fell in love with Obama, because they're mostly Democrats and were stunned to find a high-profile Dem who could walk and talk competently). The real problem is that he was reduced by this. As for the GOP, they have a new star in Paul Ryan. This was pretty much awesome for him.



The real question is, where do we go from here? Mickey Kaus makes the case for Dems passing the current health care bill on the grounds that if the sky doesn't fall after they do it, they will have called the GOP bluff. I'm not sure Democrats want to gamble on that chance. More importantly, they would need to use reconciliation in the Senate to pass the bill without stuff like the Cornhusker Kickback, and that might make the political process totally toxic for the rest of the year (if not the rest of Obama's first term). Bill Frist explains why...
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid has announced that while Democrats have a number of options to complete health-care legislation, he may use the budget reconciliation process to do so. This would be an unprecedented, dangerous and historic mistake.

Budget reconciliation is an arcane Senate procedure whereby legislation can be passed using a lowered threshold of requisite votes (a simple majority) under fast-track rules that limit debate. This process was intended for incremental changes to the budget—not sweeping social legislation.
The Democrats may want to dismiss this as a simple dispute about procedural rules and rightly claim that the GOP has used reconciliation numerous times in the past. Unfortunately for them, the GOP never used it for something this big, and the last thing the public wants (after months of seemingly corrupt backroom deals on health care) is a questionable process that passes this bill without any GOP votes. It looks dirty -- and the dirt will stick to them come November and beyond.

So will they do it? Mike Allen at Politico explains that this is the gameplan, or at least was the gameplan leading into the summit. The real question, then, is whether this summit answered the worries of nervous moderate House Dems who would have to vote for the package. I can't see that it would, but I'm not a Democrat. And if I were, I'd probably be pretty frustrated right now.

Labels: , , , , ,

Sunday, January 10, 2010

No One's Wild About Harry

Seeing as how I can't stand Harry Reid, I'm enjoying this thoroughly...
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) apologized today for referring to President Barack Obama as "light skinned" and "with no Negro dialect" in private conversations during the 2008 presidential campaign.
"I deeply regret using such a poor choice of words," said Reid in a statement. "I sincerely apologize for offending any and all Americans, especially African Americans for my improper comments."
President Obama said in a statement that he and Reid had spoken about the matter on Saturday afternoon. "I accepted Harry's apology without question because I've known him for years, I've seen the passionate leadership he's shown on issues of social justice and I know what's in his heart," said Obama. "As far as I am concerned, the book is closed."
The Senate Majority Leader was officially neutral in the primary fight between Obama and then Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton (N.Y.). Reid's remarks about Obama were revealed in "Game Change", a book detailing the 2008 race penned by Time's Mark Halperin and New York magazine's John Heilemann.
Damn shame it's after Christmas, or this would be on the book list. Then again, who needs to read it? Hot Air points out that the book also has Bill Clinton pressing Ted Kennedy to endorse Hillary, while telling him that a few years ago, "this guy (Obama) would have been getting us coffee." I tend to agree with Allahpundit's take that Slick Willie didn't mean it that way, but no Republican would ever get such benefit of the doubt. Ask Trent Lott. Reid's poll numbers already stink for re-election -- if this continues, he may need to pull a Dodd and act like he meant to retire.

Labels: , ,

Friday, December 18, 2009

The Health Care Follies Continue

I think the idea of civil war in the Democratic Party is as overblown as the talk of civil war among the GOP earlier this year, but it's still entertaining to consider the thought. Plus Howard Kurtz turns a nice opening image into a pretty substantive commentary, before providing some links that are worth exploring...
That splashing sound you hear is liberals jumping off the health care ship.

For all the talk of a Republican civil war earlier this year, it is remarkable to watch the left wing of the Democratic Party splitting off and vowing to defeat the measure that has been President Obama's top priority.

Finger-pointing is common when legislation is teetering on the brink, but the level of vitriol that has erupted in the past couple of days is nothing short of stunning.

Some liberals are angry at Howard Dean for suddenly leading the charge against the Senate bill. Others are furious at Joe Lieberman for forcing his former party to drop the remnants of a public option and Medicare buy-in. Still others are blaming Obama for letting this thing turn into an increasingly unpopular morass.

It's not that the criticism is unfair. Dean has never been much of a team player. Lieberman keeps wavering to maximize his leverage. Obama let Congress write the bills without much pushback. The Democrats have a big majority in the House and 60 votes in the Senate -- sort of -- and they still can't seem to get this done.

Harry Reid has drawn his share of criticism, but could LBJ or any other majority leader have cobbled together an acceptable compromise? When he adds something that liberals like -- the 27th iteration of a public option -- he loses moderate senators whose votes he needs to choke off a filibuster. When he makes concessions to the moderate side, the liberals get angry. Then there are the thorny side issues such as drug reimportation and abortion funding. The bill (which still must be reconciled with the House version, if the Senate gets that far) now has something for everyone to hate.

...Is it still worth passing? The president certainly didn't campaign for a public option. But to add, say, 30 million Americans to the health insurance system through a mandate -- a laudable goal, on the surface -- could really lead to soaring costs without a strong mechanism to keep prices under control. And that seems to be lacking, especially given Congress' record on calling for cuts in programs like Medicare but flinching when it's time to carry them out.

Joe Biden said on "Morning Joe" this week that health care reform would be dead for a long, long time unless this bill passes soon. And he's right. The Obama White House and the Congress made a mighty, yearlong effort in the face of near-unified GOP opposition. They're not likely to try again.

So the question for the Democrats is whether it's better to pass a flawed bill and claim victory -- even though most of the good stuff doesn't kick in for years -- or appear to be a totally dysfunctional party by failing to pass anything at all.
Strangely, I sympathize a lot with the progressive left. A lot of the best dreams of the right did not materialize during W.'s eight years, for various reasons. He compromised on school choice, for example, to get No Child Left Behind. He blew social security reform. But Obama's failures on health care are a glaring failure in a different way -- he refused to put up his political goodwill in the fight, and left the heavy lifting to Congress, which had competing priorities. The moderate Democrats in the center wanted one thing, while the liberal progressives on the left wanted something else. The President made it sound like he wanted everything, but never fully laid out where he would take a stand. This meant that people in his own party -- people who would like his Presidency to succeed -- didn't have a guiding principle to follow in the process. The question is why. Glenn Greenwald, of all people, does a great job laying the blame at the White House's feet, but seems to think this is all part of the White House strategy...
Of all the posts I wrote this year, the one that produced the most vociferous email backlash -- easily -- was this one from August, which examined substantial evidence showing that, contrary to Obama's occasional public statements in support of a public option, the White House clearly intended from the start that the final health care reform bill would contain no such provision and was actively and privately participating in efforts to shape a final bill without it. From the start, assuaging the health insurance and pharmaceutical industries was a central preoccupation of the White House -- hence the deal negotiated in strict secrecy with Pharma to ban bulk price negotiations and drug reimportation, a blatant violation of both Obama's campaign positions on those issues and his promise to conduct all negotiations out in the open (on C-SPAN). Indeed, Democrats led the way yesterday in killing drug re-importation, which they endlessly claimed to support back when they couldn't pass it. The administration wants not only to prevent industry money from funding an anti-health-care-reform campaign, but also wants to ensure that the Democratic Party -- rather than the GOP -- will continue to be the prime recipient of industry largesse.
As was painfully predictable all along, the final bill will not have any form of public option, nor will it include the wildly popular expansion of Medicare coverage. Obama supporters are eager to depict the White House as nothing more than a helpless victim in all of this -- the President so deeply wanted a more progressive bill but was sadly thwarted in his noble efforts by those inhumane, corrupt Congressional "centrists." Right. The evidence was overwhelming from the start that the White House was not only indifferent, but opposed, to the provisions most important to progressives. The administration is getting the bill which they, more or less, wanted from the start -- the one that is a huge boon to the health insurance and pharmaceutical industry. And
kudos to Russ Feingold for saying so:
Sen. Russ Feingold (D-Wis.), among the most vocal supporters of the public option, said it would be unfair to blame Lieberman for its apparent demise. Feingold said that responsibility ultimately rests with President Barack Obama and he could have insisted on a higher standard for the legislation.
"This bill appears to be legislation that the president wanted in the first place, so I don’t think focusing it on Lieberman really hits the truth," said Feingold. "I think they could have been higher. I certainly think a stronger bill would have been better in every respect."
Let's repeat that: "This bill appears to be legislation that the president wanted in the first place." Indeed it does. There are rational, practical reasons why that might be so. If you're interested in preserving and expanding political power, then, all other things being equal, it's better to have the pharmaceutical and health insurance industry on your side than opposed to you. Or perhaps they calculated from the start that this was the best bill they could get. The wisdom of that rationale can be debated, but depicting Obama as the impotent progressive victim here of recalcitrant, corrupt centrists is really too much to bear.
Of course, this imagines that the President's allegedly brilliant maneuvering (although Greenwald seems to think the maneuvering has been a load of hooey as well) will produce a bill that passes, and that's in question. What's not in question is that the process of putting together the bill, in the face of mounting public opposition and an economic crisis, has put a severe dent in the Democrats' chances of maintaining control of the House and keeping a filibuster-proof Senate majority. I know I'm hoping for the failure of this bill, but both sides are now fully invested in getting Ben Nelson on their side in Nebraska. He seems to be the final vote that Harry Reid needs, but let's not forget Jim Webb as well. If Webb suddenly throws a wrench in the process, the Dems could be in for a depressing holiday break. I think Webb will actually vote for cloture and then against the bill, but I could be wrong.

There's a tight schedule by which Reid might get the bill approved before Christmas. Of course, now Mother Nature may screw with the schedule as well. And if this thing doesn't get passed before the New Year... well, it gets more unpopular by the minute. By President's Day, health care reform might be less popular than swine flu.

Labels: , , , ,

Tuesday, December 15, 2009

The Health Care Follies Continue

Hey, we've finally got a good explanation of the public option...



(hat tip: Randy Barnett at Volokh)

Too bad this explanation wasn't available earlier -- it might have eased passage of the public option, as we'd all be too distracted by the cartoon. That might be the most effective way to pass the bill, now that I think about it -- pass it, then pretend nothing happened.

I should stop now, before I give Harry Reid any ideas.

Labels: ,

Monday, November 23, 2009

The Health Care Follies Continue

I hoped to talk more about the farce of the health care reform bill, but Harry Reid went and got the Senate debate started on Saturday by the skin of his teeth, in a move that only makes sense if you intend to force-feed a bill down America's throats in time for Christmas. But Byron York notes how much remains to be done for Reid and the Democrats...
"If the bill remains where it is now, I will not be able to support a cloture motion before final passage," Sen. Joseph Lieberman said. "I'm prepared to vote against moving to the next stage of consideration as long as a government-run public option is included," said Sen. Blanche Lincoln. "My vote to move forward on this important debate should in no way be construed by the supporters of this current framework as an indication of how I might vote as this debate comes to an end," said Sen. Mary Landrieu. And Sen. Ben Nelson said he will "oppose the second cloture motion -- needing 60 votes -- to end debate, and oppose the final bill" if major changes are not made.

Some of that is the normal positioning and bargaining that takes place when big bills are considered. But the Democrats' problems in keeping their side together, in the face of united Republican opposition, are an indicator of how public opinion is beginning to dominate the health care debate. Dozens of polls show that Americans are deeply divided over the issue, with a slight plurality opposing the Democratic health care plans currently under consideration in Congress. Clear majorities of Americans don't believe their health care will improve under the plan, and do believe the plan will increase the deficit. Given that, Democrats are trying to pass the biggest piece of legislation in decades, one that will create an enormous and permanent new entitlement, with less than majority support among the public. And they're racing to do it with less than a year to go before mid-term elections that most observers believe will result in fewer Democrats in Congress. No wonder it's hard.
It says a lot that with massive majorities in both houses, the Democrats suddenly face razon-thin vote margins on their signature issue. Part of this is posturing, particularly in the House (where Pelosi and Emanuel were probably able to buy another 5 votes if needed), but a bigger part of this is the shift in public opinion. Actually, there's two shifts here at play.

The first is that the American public's appetite for reform is waning, at least in the current evironment. Between concerns about the deficit, the specifics of the legislation (will illegal aliens be covered? will there a public option? will Medicare be cut?), and the general opposition to big government solutions as people have grown sour on the non-working stimulus and bailouts, health care reform doesn't poll well. The liberals seem to be hoping that if they pass the bill, it will end the debate. I think that's foolish from an electoral point of view, but it is true that it's exceptionally hard to kill an entitlement program once it's established (although our expanding debt will soon test that theory). No matter what, it would be hard to argue that reform is getting more popular -- some surveys indicate it's less popular now than ever before.

But the second shift isn't just on the policy -- it's on Barack Obama. The President's approval ratings are slipping, so much so that people are joking about the narrowing spread between his approval versus that of Sarah Palin's. I don't think Obama's got a problem regarding Palin in 2012 -- I doubt she gets the nomination. But he does have a problem with the American public -- they're not fascinated by the shiny new politician in the window anymore. He's just the President -- they like (or increasingly, used to like) the guy, but expect him to do the job in a certain way. And when he doesn't, or they disagree with him, he hasn't been able to persuade them that he is right.

That last point is important. One of Obama's key advantages in the 2008 election was the perception that his golden tongue could lead people to support his policy initiatives. Yet on health care, a signature issue, he has not been able to rally new supporters around his ideas of reform -- in fact, he's been totally incapable of drawing support from the other side of the aisle. If Bush was President, we'd hear about how he's not being bipartisan. In this case, we hear about how the GOP is being obstructionist.

But in the end, it's on Obama. From day one, he's failed to articulate how his reform will work to (a) cover more people, (b) cut costs, (c) allow all of the people who like their own coverage to keep it, and (d) keep from imposing taxes on anyone save people making $250k or more a year. That's mostly because he can't do it (all of the above can't be done together), but the continuing attempt to sell it on these terms is so dishonest that the corrupt parts of the process are a sideshow. When we learned that Reid had to buy off Mary Landrieu with $100 million in aid for Louisiana simply to get the bill to the floor, it wasn't surprising. Given the rush to enact this powergrab without a real opportunity for the public to consider it, and then the continuing rush to enact it when the public has vociferously objected, it's not surprising that the legislation is unpopular. But the President's failure to convince a majority of why they should support it would have been shocking a year ago.

But now, it's common knowledge that Obama's oratory has been insufficient. That's why Obama is in trouble, whether he passes this piece of crap legislation or not.

Labels: , , , , ,